Working Women: A symbol of regressive society?

05:39 Dr. Monica Gupta 0 Comments

Recently, I received a video through whatsapp ‘In conversation with the Mystic’, where Juhi Chawla was eliciting mystic’s views on should women work or take care of the family. One of the group members asked for everyone’s opinion on the subject of women working. This made me think; like the mystic I too believe that every individual has a right to self expression, so does a woman. However, for me these two are not mutually exclusive. A woman can work and take care of the family as well. Besides, to me it is about choosing what is right for you and your family.


Regressive Society

As per mystic’s views working women are a symbol of regressive society. A progressive society according to him is one where women are house wives (homemakers). To me, this view itself is regressive because a society where an individual cannot choose their lifestyle and is forced to act against their will is regressive. Rather, a society which offers similar opportunities to men and women is a progressive one. Hence, the trend of women working to contribute to the family or even for self satisfaction and sense of achievement is a symbol of progress.

Nurturing Environment

So, first of all, if a woman chooses to work she should go ahead and do it because I believe and speak out of experience that a working woman can also provide a nurturing environment, if she chooses to. Off course, it would mean opting for lesser personal time, socialization and social interaction which is more than compensated for with professional interaction and satisfaction. However it's your choice and there shouldn't be any complaints or obligation to the family.

Similarly, if a woman chooses to devote her time to the family, nothing like that. I remember the comfort of knowing that my mother was always available to welcome and attend to us whatever the time or situation. I credit my mother a great deal to what I am today.

Having said this, quite a few house wives engage in meaningful activities like taking on part time assignments, freelancing, taking tuitions, coaching, dance, music, painting, cooking, baking, and yoga classes; running small time businesses through whats app or network marketing, thereby choosing to work from home. Again they have found a way of striking a balance which suits them; a healthy way to devote time for the family and also find ways of self expression.

As there are always two sides of a coin and the numbers on both sides in this case are substantial, it is also worth mentioning, there are some who have redefined the role of a house wife. The cook does the cooking, children go for tuitions, and frequent kitty parties are call of the day. Giving fuel to the increasing feeling among gen next that house wives are a liability for the society instead of being an asset. From a solution oriented perspective a slight change in thought with the same lifestyle can reverse the sides of the coin. For example, kitty parties could delve on societal issues or take up social work.

I would rather subscribe to the latest term ‘Homemaker’, which to me truly conveys the essence of being a housewife. A homemaker is one, as described by the mystic as well, who provides the nurturing environment and atmosphere for the family to excel in their respective chosen paths. I remember that my father could fully devote himself to his profession because my mother was there for us. Off course, there are many examples which may fit this description of a homemaker. So, basically, what I mean to say is that if you choose to be a house wife, do full justice and carry no regrets and there is no obligation to the family because it's your choice. At the end, I'd say it's a collective decision and choice of the family on how we want to lead our life and what is fulfilling for us.

Of course, it would be amiss if I do not mention that all working women may not be striking the correct balance between work and family leading to stress and unfulfilled aspirations and expectations. So, it is all about freedom to choose and then justifying it by ensuring that whatever the choice, you stand true to yourself and your family.

Bread Winner

As per mystic’s views an ideal situation would be where men are bread winners and women take care of the family. Maybe, at the same time, there are no ideal situations in life. You gain some and you lose some. There are always advantages and disadvantages of the choices we make. Attempt should be to optimize the pros over the cons.

Again, there is another model, less tried, but can definitely be successful where the woman is the bread winner and the man the homemaker. This too can prove to be fulfilling and satisfying as each one of us are born with different traits. Generally by nature women are more nurturing and caring and therefore even in the animal kingdom (mostly) we see that the female cares for the young ones. A couple where the man has the traits suited to the nurturer’s role and the woman that of a provider’s; there could be a role reversal, leaving everyone happier and fulfilled. In fact, many cultures have women donning the primary role. For example, in the North East Indian Garo tribe, women are dominant.

Women Work for Money and Material Benefits

The belief that women work just to earn money and acquire material benefits for themselves and the family is totally misplaced. There are always outliner cases, which cannot be used to generalize a social trend. Some may need to work to make both ends meet or to provide for better opportunities for their families. There are many working women who are in the game for self expression and a sense of satisfaction for having achieved in their lives. Education industry is replete with examples of women who have gainfully put their professional qualifications to use and at the same time are active homemakers.

It is not necessary that every woman works for remuneration. There are many who work for NGO’s, are social activist, and social workers.  History has also seen many women take on the leadership or a professional role. The British Empire itself was lead by different queens at different points of time. Similarly, Madam Curie is another example who immediately comes to mind besides so many achievers in today’s time.  We have many successful contemporary examples in front of us like Indira Nooyi, Chanda Kochhar, Shikha Sharma, Aishwarya Rai Bachchan, Juhi Chawla, Sonali Bendre, Sudha Murthy, Mallika Srinivasan Meenakshi Lekhi from different walks of life and the list can go on.  Where there is a will, there is a way.


At the end, whatever you do be proud of your choice and respect others for their choice.


Incoming Search Terms :

Working Women, Society, Regressive Society, Symbol, Progressive Society, Women Empowerment

0 comments: